Columbus's Favorite Craft Pizzeria

We Don't Slice Pizza. We Craft It.

Hand-tossed dough fermented 72 hours. House-made San Marzano sauce. Toppings sourced from Ohio farms. This is pizza made by people who actually care.

Call to Order View Menu

Fresh craft pizza from American Pie Pizza Columbus

72hr

Dough Fermentation

100%

Ohio Sourced

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Loved Locally

OUR MENU

Crafted with Obsession

Every pizza tells a story — of slow-fermented dough, fire-kissed crust, and ingredients that taste like they came from your neighbor's garden.

Classic Pepperoni pizza with crispy edges

The Classic

Signature

San Marzano tomato sauce, whole-milk mozzarella, cup-and-char pepperoni, dried oregano, extra virgin olive oil finish.

Hand-tossed • 12" • Wood-fired

Fig & Prosciutto

Popular

Brown butter base, fresh figs, prosciutto di Parma, goat cheese, arugula, balsamic reduction drizzle, shaved Parmigiano.

Gourmet • 12" • Wood-fired

Hot Honey Heat

Spicy

Arrabbiata sauce, smoked mozzarella, soppressata, Calabrian chili, roasted red peppers, drizzled with local hot honey.

Bold • 12" • Wood-fired

Margherita D.O.P.

Classic

San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella from Upstate NY, fresh basil, sea salt, extra virgin olive oil. Simple perfection.

Vegetarian • 12" • Wood-fired

Truffle mushroom pizza with wild mushrooms

Truffle Wild

Premium

Roasted garlic cream base, wild mushroom medley, fontina, truffle oil, fresh thyme, finished with shaved black truffle.

Earthy • 12" • Wood-fired

Garden State

Seasonal

Roasted pepperoncini, zucchini, cherry tomatoes, Kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, feta, fresh oregano, lemon zest finish.

Fresh • 12" • Wood-fired

Menu items rotate seasonally. Call (614) 443-8520 for today's specials.

Pizza chef preparing dough at American Pie Pizza

Since

Columbus

OUR STORY

Pizza People Who Actually Know Pizza

American Pie Pizza wasn't born in a boardroom. It was born at a kitchen table, with flour on the counter and a stubborn belief that Columbus deserved better than delivery box mediocrity.

We ferment our dough for 72 hours because fast food shouldn't wear our name. We source from Ohio farms because food tastes better when it hasn't been on a truck for three days. Every pizza that leaves our oven carries a simple promise: we made this like it was for ourselves.

72hr

Dough Fermentation

100%

Ohio Ingredients

900°F

Wood-Fired Oven

5min

Average Bake Time

FIND US

Come Say Hello

We're right here in Columbus. Walk in, call ahead, or swing by — your pizza's waiting.

Address

2505 Parsons Ave
Columbus, OH 43207

Phone

(614) 443-8520

Call to place orders or ask questions

Hours

Monday – Thursday 11am – 9pm

Friday – Saturday 11am – 10pm

Sunday 12pm – 8pm

Ready for Real Pizza?

Stop settling for sad, soggy delivery. Call us now and taste the difference that craft makes.

(614) 443-8520 Get Directions